The Roll
- 4GW, IO & Intel
- Abu Muqawama
- Arms Control Wonk
- Danger Room
- Global Security Newswire
- Haft of the Spear
- Intel Dump
- Mountain Runner
- Nukes & Spooks
- Pakistan Defence
- PogoWasRight
- Question Everything
- Rethink Afghanistan
- Sic Semper Tyrannis
- Small Wars Journal
- Spies for Hire
- Swedish Meatballs Confidential
- Swiss Whistleblower
- Tim Shorrock
- Waq al-Waq
- War in Context
- War is Boring
- World War 4 Report
- Congo Watch
- Breaking the Silence
- Concerned Africa Scholars
- Stealth Conflicts
- Stop the War in North Kivu
- Document Archives
- AfterDowningStreet
- Amped Status
- cloudprivacy
- Cryptome
- Dark Data
- FreeDocumentaries.org
- government attic
- Information Clearing House
- Newsmine
- NSWBC Archives
- Smoking Gun
- Economics & Markets
- Angry Bear
- Baseline Scenario
- Calculated Risk
- Daily Reckoning
- Dollars and Sense
- Econbrowser
- Economist's View
- Global Financial Integrity
- Implode-O-Meter
- Mogambo Guru
- New Economist
- Nouriel Roubini
- Rude Awakening
- Sanity Check
- The Big Picture
- The Financial
- Visualizing Economics
- Zero Hedge
- Elections Watch
- Avi Rubin
- Bradblog
- Election Defense Alliance
- Election Fraud News
- News from Underground
- Solar Bus
- Energy & Oil
- Energy & Capital
- Energy Bulletin
- Herald Energy
- NewsNow Oil
- The Oil and the Glory
- The Oil Drum
- In Depth
- Chompers
- Consortium News
- Counterpunch
- Crisis Papers
- Defensetech
- F. William Engdahl
- In These Times
- Multinational Monitor
- Pragati
- The Public Record
- TomDispatch
- Wallerstein
- WhoWhatWhy
- International Media
- Asia Times
- BBC
- CBC
- DutchNews
- Financial Times
- Globe & Mail
- Guardian
- Ha'aretz
- Hindu
- IHT
- Independent
- Middle East Online
- Reuters World News
- The National (UAE)
- The NEWS
- Times of India
- Upside Down World
- War and Peace
- Journals
- EDGE
- Hobgoblin
- Le Monde Diplomatique
- Miller-McCune
- Monthly Review
- Pambazuka News
- Radical Philosophy
- The Humanist
- Legal Eagles
- Balkinization
- Is That Legal?
- Lawyers, Guns and Money
- LIFT
- Media Watch
- Ad Busters
- BAGnewsNotes
- Center for Citizen Media
- Daily Censored
- Daily Howler
- ePluribus Media
- FAIR
- Media Matters
- Nieman Watchdog
- NPR Check
- Spinwatch
- Stop Big Media
- WhoWhatWhy
- Must See TV
- Al Jazeera
- Fault Lines
- GRITtv
- History of Oil
- Listening Post
- Mosaic
- Political Prosecutions
- Russia Today
- The Revolution Will Not Be Televised
- The Secret Government
- Torturing Democracy
- Policy Watch
- Boiling Frogs
- BRussells Tribunal
- Current Intelligence
- Democracy Arsenal
- Foreign Policy
- Foreign Policy in Focus
- Global Policy Forum
- Global Research
- Global Sociology
- Global Witness
- GlobalSecurity.org
- IC Global Affairs
- Institute for Policy R&D
- Institute for Southern Studies
- ISN/EHT Zurich
- Rethink Aghanistan
- SHAFR
- SOA Watch
- Strategic Security
- Trita Parsi
- William Pfaff
- Political Video
- Brasscheck TV
- Crooks and Liars
- John Ennis TV
- Real News
- All Things Pass
- AlterNet
- American Chronicle
- Baltimore Brew
- Capitol Hill Blue
- Environment Newswire
- Flashpoints Radio
- Flesh & Stone
- History News Network
- Information Liberation
- Inter Press
- Irin News
- Legit Gov
- Mad Cow
- MAMA Radio (Columbia)
- Media Freedom Foundation
- Monsters & Critics
- Narco News
- OpEd News
- Project Censored
- ProPublica
- Raw Story
- Scoop
- Secrecy News
- The Free Press
- TPM Muckraker
- Truthdig
- Tyee
- Washington Independent
- WSWS
- Rhizomatic Trim
- Agonist
- American Politics Journal
- American Samizdat
- Antifacist Calling ...
- APOV
- Back to Iraq
- Booman Tribune
- Carta Blanc
- Chycho
- Clusterfuck Nation
- Covert History
- Dandelion Salad
- Decline of the Empire
- Empire Burlesque
- Horse's Ass
- Mercury Rising
- Monbiot
- NewsHoggers
- Northman's Fury
- Pen and Sword
- Regressive Antidote
- Roads to Iraq
- Smirking Chimp
- The Osterley Times
- Think Progress
- Toner Mishap
- War and Piece
- Washington Babylon
- Winter Patriot
- ZERO ANTHROPOLOGY
- Slapping idiots
- Pharyngula
- Real Climate
- Slurp
- BigNews
- BuzzFlash
- Digg
- Google News
- memeorandum
- My Way News
- Newstin
- Popurls
- Radical Reference
- schema-root
- SOTT News
- Uruknet
- What Really Happened
- Wikio
- World News
- Worldwide Sawdust
- Tech
- Ars Technica
- cnet
- Register
- Tech Crunch
- Wired
- US Commercial Media
- Military Times
- NY Times
- The Blotter
- UPI
- WaPo
- Vue International
- 'Aqoul
- Abiding in Bolivia
- africa comments
- Bernard Avishai
- BoRev.Net
- China Confidential
- Cutting Edge
- Der Spiegel
- Gary's Choices
- Healing Iraq
- Hevallo
- Informed Comment
- Inside South America
- MESH
- News of the Restless
- Palestinian Pundit
- Postcards from the Revolution
- Registan
- Siddharth Varadarajan
- Syria Comment
Shockfront
Recent Posts
- Tricks of the Libyan Trade
- Mubarak is gone
- Sino-Russian oil pipeline goes operational
- Obama DoJ Refuses Cooperation on Polish "CIA Black Site" Investigation
- Iran Suspends Fuel Delivery to Afghanistan
- Halliburton settles, Cheney skates
- "We are filing charges against Cheney"
- Students Storm La Torre di Pisa, Colosseum
- "Evidence of Informed Trading on the Attacks of September 11"
- "Drones Strikes Based on Scant Evidence"
Archives
- May 2011
- February 2011
- January 2011
- December 2010
- November 2010
- October 2010
- September 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
Shockfront
Wednesday, 16 April 2008
The Secretary of State Torture
[Update below]
"Propaganda is not meant to fool the intelligencia, it is merely meant to provide them an excuse to avoid seeing ugly realities they'd sooner not believe."
"It is not propaganda’s task to be intelligent, its task is to lead to success."-- Joseph Goebbles
Hotpotatomash posted this video, but it is well done and so wanted to post it here, "for the record."
While Robert Greenwald's new short film argues that the mounting evidence demands Condoleezza Rice resign from office as Secretary of State,it is more compelling than that. In fact, the film and the larger story surrounding it, impugn the "highest levels" of the Bush administration as authors of a fully articulated torture program. Yes, Rice repeatedly claimed that the "United States does not torture," (true on some level -- most of the United States does not torture people -- just Bush officials) but this dissembling rhetoric was spouted by every one of those high level officials who participated in these meetings, most of whom are now gone. Except Cheney. And obviously he should go, too. But we know how likely that is. Considering the near complete media silence on this issue in the aftermath of the story, not only will Rice's resignation remain unconsidered, but the White House would disregard any such calls. Fortunately for Bush, and unfortunately for the state of the union, I think we can all see that he won't be placed in the uncomfortable position of having to defend Rice. If you watched the Democratic "debate" Wednesday night, you will understand that. (Oddly, it was ABC, one of the outlets that broke the White House torture meetings story, that was also responsible for the inconsequential nonsense that formed much of the discussion.)
Perhaps a far more effective avenue of reproach would be for international diplomats world-wide to simply refuse to talk or even meet with Rice, rendering her even more useless than she has been already. I doubt this would shame the White House -- nothing does -- into removing her, but it would certainly send a clear message that the world has had quite enough of the Bush administration and their preposterous claims of moral leadership on the world stage. One thing is at least certain, however. Any, any notions Rice may have entertained for a future political career are over. Done. At the end of Bush's term, she would do well to quietly slink off to a very private life and hope no one tries to prosecute her for war crimes and crimes against humanity.
Though they will not be forthcoming, calls for resignation, though perhaps more realistic than impeachment, are wholly inadequate. Impeachment of each and everyone one of the participants, and the clown prince who signed off on their choreography, is demanded and required as a matter of law. Democrats are obviously unlikely to pursue this, since it seems likely that at least a few of them had some indication about what was going on and therefore could be found guilty of aiding and abetting or, at least, accessory after the fact. Which is precisely why Congress will not pursue the matter. Because they are still accessory after the fact. And though the evidence is now overwhelming, the unbridled criminality of the country's highest officials will remain forever, not only unpunished but underreported by the corporate media. Hats off to ABC and AP for their reports, but they are reverberating almost nowhere.
No, the most pressing concern for this country's wretched political class, however, continues to be Obama's "out of touch" claim that Americans are "bitter." Forfend that thought, say the television meatheads. Americans can't be bitter. That just can't be. They live in America! And what with this being America, why, "small town" Americans must be slavishly optimistic to the myth that has been shoved down their throats since childhood. Work hard, work harder, dream the impossible dream, watch pensions disappear and health care evaporate, work harder still, get fucked over again and again and watch the corporate overlords reap uncountable riches. Remain optimistic, however, because this is America! No, no one could be bitter about that arrangement. Obama is clearly an out-of-touch elitist.
This is the media meme of the day and will remain so for many days, at least until enough time has passed for that unpleasant business that the Bush cabinet "choreographed" a torture program at the highest levels and then lied about it. Bear those words of Goebbels in mind, when considering what you are witnessing taking place in the US media -- the endless Obama "analysis" while an uncomfortable and ugly truth floats suspended and ignored.
There is a subtle psyop in play in the media here, though most will be unaware of just what is going on. Despite the fact that reports like that delivered by ABC News can be broadcast, demonstrating a free press, the fact that almost none of the talking heads, distracted by and distracting with the phony Obama "gaff," even bother to discuss the serious breach of law represented in the report has a certain effect. And that effect is one of dismissal through elision; that by failing to follow-up on such a report with the brio of the media's self-styled talking heads, where the import of such a story would be amplified by orders of magnitude -- as it should be -- ignoring the torturous facts swirling around the Bush administration conveys a message of insignificance. If no one is talking about it, it can't be important.
We see this constantly in the media and, as McLuhan so long ago observed, the media do not simply convey messages, they are the message. What they say, goes. And what they don't say goes nowhere. Perhaps the internet has changed that some degree, but this still remains largely true. And it is especially true for those "small town" Americans, even more so if they happen to live in such towns that beneficent telecom companies have deigned delivery of internet service, which thereby prevents those impossibly optimistic folks from watching videos like the one above and possibly -- just possibly -- getting bitter about it.
Update:Perhaps you are one of those hopelessly naive souls who might think that, yeah, all those higher-ups talked about "enhanced interrogation," but "slapping" and "pushing" hardly sound that bad. C'mon!
If this is the case, and you think that this interrogation technique fails to meet any normative criterion for cruelty, please inform yourself otherwise with an autoposy report from the Armed Forces Institute for Pathology that is now being highlighted in various outlets. The examination was of an inmate held by US forces at Al Asad, Iraq.
"Propaganda is not meant to fool the intelligencia, it is merely meant to provide them an excuse to avoid seeing ugly realities they'd sooner not believe."
"It is not propaganda’s task to be intelligent, its task is to lead to success."-- Joseph Goebbles
Hotpotatomash posted this video, but it is well done and so wanted to post it here, "for the record."
While Robert Greenwald's new short film argues that the mounting evidence demands Condoleezza Rice resign from office as Secretary of State,it is more compelling than that. In fact, the film and the larger story surrounding it, impugn the "highest levels" of the Bush administration as authors of a fully articulated torture program. Yes, Rice repeatedly claimed that the "United States does not torture," (true on some level -- most of the United States does not torture people -- just Bush officials) but this dissembling rhetoric was spouted by every one of those high level officials who participated in these meetings, most of whom are now gone. Except Cheney. And obviously he should go, too. But we know how likely that is. Considering the near complete media silence on this issue in the aftermath of the story, not only will Rice's resignation remain unconsidered, but the White House would disregard any such calls. Fortunately for Bush, and unfortunately for the state of the union, I think we can all see that he won't be placed in the uncomfortable position of having to defend Rice. If you watched the Democratic "debate" Wednesday night, you will understand that. (Oddly, it was ABC, one of the outlets that broke the White House torture meetings story, that was also responsible for the inconsequential nonsense that formed much of the discussion.)
Perhaps a far more effective avenue of reproach would be for international diplomats world-wide to simply refuse to talk or even meet with Rice, rendering her even more useless than she has been already. I doubt this would shame the White House -- nothing does -- into removing her, but it would certainly send a clear message that the world has had quite enough of the Bush administration and their preposterous claims of moral leadership on the world stage. One thing is at least certain, however. Any, any notions Rice may have entertained for a future political career are over. Done. At the end of Bush's term, she would do well to quietly slink off to a very private life and hope no one tries to prosecute her for war crimes and crimes against humanity.
Though they will not be forthcoming, calls for resignation, though perhaps more realistic than impeachment, are wholly inadequate. Impeachment of each and everyone one of the participants, and the clown prince who signed off on their choreography, is demanded and required as a matter of law. Democrats are obviously unlikely to pursue this, since it seems likely that at least a few of them had some indication about what was going on and therefore could be found guilty of aiding and abetting or, at least, accessory after the fact. Which is precisely why Congress will not pursue the matter. Because they are still accessory after the fact. And though the evidence is now overwhelming, the unbridled criminality of the country's highest officials will remain forever, not only unpunished but underreported by the corporate media. Hats off to ABC and AP for their reports, but they are reverberating almost nowhere.
No, the most pressing concern for this country's wretched political class, however, continues to be Obama's "out of touch" claim that Americans are "bitter." Forfend that thought, say the television meatheads. Americans can't be bitter. That just can't be. They live in America! And what with this being America, why, "small town" Americans must be slavishly optimistic to the myth that has been shoved down their throats since childhood. Work hard, work harder, dream the impossible dream, watch pensions disappear and health care evaporate, work harder still, get fucked over again and again and watch the corporate overlords reap uncountable riches. Remain optimistic, however, because this is America! No, no one could be bitter about that arrangement. Obama is clearly an out-of-touch elitist.
This is the media meme of the day and will remain so for many days, at least until enough time has passed for that unpleasant business that the Bush cabinet "choreographed" a torture program at the highest levels and then lied about it. Bear those words of Goebbels in mind, when considering what you are witnessing taking place in the US media -- the endless Obama "analysis" while an uncomfortable and ugly truth floats suspended and ignored.
There is a subtle psyop in play in the media here, though most will be unaware of just what is going on. Despite the fact that reports like that delivered by ABC News can be broadcast, demonstrating a free press, the fact that almost none of the talking heads, distracted by and distracting with the phony Obama "gaff," even bother to discuss the serious breach of law represented in the report has a certain effect. And that effect is one of dismissal through elision; that by failing to follow-up on such a report with the brio of the media's self-styled talking heads, where the import of such a story would be amplified by orders of magnitude -- as it should be -- ignoring the torturous facts swirling around the Bush administration conveys a message of insignificance. If no one is talking about it, it can't be important.
We see this constantly in the media and, as McLuhan so long ago observed, the media do not simply convey messages, they are the message. What they say, goes. And what they don't say goes nowhere. Perhaps the internet has changed that some degree, but this still remains largely true. And it is especially true for those "small town" Americans, even more so if they happen to live in such towns that beneficent telecom companies have deigned delivery of internet service, which thereby prevents those impossibly optimistic folks from watching videos like the one above and possibly -- just possibly -- getting bitter about it.
Update:Perhaps you are one of those hopelessly naive souls who might think that, yeah, all those higher-ups talked about "enhanced interrogation," but "slapping" and "pushing" hardly sound that bad. C'mon!
If this is the case, and you think that this interrogation technique fails to meet any normative criterion for cruelty, please inform yourself otherwise with an autoposy report from the Armed Forces Institute for Pathology that is now being highlighted in various outlets. The examination was of an inmate held by US forces at Al Asad, Iraq.
Circumstances of Death: Iraqi detainee died while in U.S. custody.And the final medical conclusion.
Authorization for Autopsy: Office of the Armed Forces Medical Examiner, lAW 10 USC 1471
Identification: Identification by accompanying paperwork and wristband, both of which include his name and a detainee number, 3ACR1582
CAUSE OF DEATH: Blunt Force. Injuries and Asphyxia
MANNER OF DEATH: Homicide
FINAL AUTOPSY DIAGNOSES:
I. Multiple Blunt Force Injuries
A. Cutaneous abrasions and contusions of the scalp, torso, and extremities
B. Deep contusions of the chest wall musculature and abdominal wall
C. Multiple, bilateral, displaced and comminuted rib fractures, with lacerations of the pleura.
D. Bilateral lung contusions
E. Bilateral hemothoraces
F. Hemorrhage into the mesentery of the small and large bowel
G. Hemorrhage into the left sternohyoid muscle with associated fractures of the thyroid cartilage and hyoid bone
II. History of Asphyxia, Secondary to Occlusion of the Oral Airway
III. Pleural and Pulmonary Adhesions
…
OPINIONPushing.
This 47-year-old White male, [redacted], died of blunt force injuries and asphyxia. The autopsy disclosed multiple blunt force injuries,including deep contusions of the chest wall, numerous displaced rib fractures, lung contusions, and hemorrhage into the mesentery of the small and large intestine. An examination of the neck structures revealed hemorrhage into the strap muscles and fractures of the thyroid cartilage and hyoid bone. According to the investigative report provided by U.S. Army CID, the decedent was shackled to the top of a doorframe with a gag in his mouth at the time he lost consciousness and became pulseless. The severe blunt force injuries, the hanging position, and the obstruction of the oral cavity with a gag contributed to this individual's death. The manner of death is homicide.
Trackback URL for this blog entry: